Health Productivity

Perfectionism is a Self-Sabotaging Trait that is Making Your Life Worse

By Jon Rumens on 26 April 2021

Table of Contents

Striving for perfection is preventing you from achieving your best.

We all want to be the best versions of ourselves. When we fail to do something to the best of our ability, most of us hold ourselves accountable and use that as a motivator to improve. That’s a good thing, as it prevents us from settling for less than our best.

But perfectionists take it to the next level. They create ideals and hold themselves to incredibly high standards that are unachievable. No matter what they do, they always fall short and pick out the negative. Because of that, perfectionists rarely think what they do is good enough.

What’s ironic, according to the research of professor Niki Hayatbini (Miami University,) is that perfectionism creates a self-fulfilling prophecy: it stunts our growth and hinders our ability to work. Therefore, it prevents us from ever achieving the incredibly high standards that it sets.

Perfectionism stands in the way of perfection. Rather than striving for an impossible standard, you would be better off accepting your imperfect achievements in all their glory.

The Negative Consequences of Perfectionism

work-from-home-forest-view

The goal of perfectionism is to make your life and everything you achieve perfect. Rather than doing so, this logical fallacy (also known as The Nirvana Fallacy is making your life significantly worse for several reasons.

It Causes Productive Procrastination

According to Entrepreneur Aytekin Tank, when we obsess over analyzing what’s missing or broken, we can’t make real progress. When a task is done to an acceptable standard, perfectionists waste time on minor details, and their overall productivity suffers.

Perfectionists experience anxiety and stress over unimportant things. Nobody is perfect, and nothing you do will ever be faultless. Rather than moving on when the jobs done, they fixate on the negative.

Clinical psychologist Alice Boyes puts it best:

“Perfectionism is often driven by striving for excellence, but it can be self-sabotaging if it leads to suboptimal behavior like continuing habits beyond their usefulness, overdelivering when you don’t have to, or overthinking every decision you make.”

It Causes us to Avoid Challenges

Niki Hayatbini’s research suggests perfectionism stems from a deficiency in cognitive flexibility. This leads to all or nothing thinking; you either pass or fail, something is either perfect or it’s not. There is no in-between. Perfection is near impossible to achieve. With their cognitive inflexibility, most think that no matter what they do they will fail.

As a result, perfectionism leads to procrastination. When they think something is too difficult or impossible, they decide to put it off until later. Others avoid taking on challenges altogether, as they try to “win by not losing.”  

It’s Damaging to our Mental Health

Rather than appreciating the world as it is, perfectionism tells us to discount reality by comparing it to the “perfect world,” or an impossible standard. That can be extremely damaging to our mental health. Rather than stopping to relax and truly appreciate the world around them, perfectionists are constantly stressing over the imperfections around them.

When they fail to reach impossible standards, they are forced to adopt a number of defense tactics to save themselves from embarrassment. They try to push the task to the back of their mind. In the long run, this leads to a heightened level of stress and worry.

It’s no surprise that the World Health Organization links perfectionism with depression, suicidal thoughts, and a number of anxiety disorders.

How to Battle Perfectionism

Now we know the negative impact that perfectionism has on our life, we can work on combatting it.

1. Stop Ruminating

As we have already identified, most perfectionists are constantly analyzing and overthinking problems, without ever arriving at a solution. According to writer Rebecca Black, ruminating is closely linked with anxiety and is extremely unproductive, so we need to break the cycle.

You can stop dwelling on imperfections by distracting yourself with another cognitively absorbing task. Rather than overthinking or overanalyzing something, once you’ve completed a task, distract yourself with a podcast or go for a walk with a friend. Because, according to Aytekin Tank:

“Spending even a short time on a mundane task can get you out of the negative headspace that leads to obsessing over details.”

Use FocusMe

Distracting yourself can be difficult, especially when you’re absorbed by perfectionism. When you’ve completed a digital task: like a University essay or a work report, we recommend using Blocker Software like FocusMe. Once the task is done, you can block it out, which will prevent you from returning to it and dwelling on the details.

2. Track Your Progress

Track Your Progress

To overcome perfectionism, you need to fight back against all-or-nothing thinking. Just because something is imperfect, doesn’t mean you have failed. To do so, Black recommends taking a “weekly review” to assess how far you’ve come and the things you have achieved. 

Even if you’ve fallen short of an impossible standard, by reminding yourself of your progress, you can retrain your mind to focus on the positive, rather than dwelling on the negative.

Better still, doing so will enable you to see how your past failings helped you learn from your mistakes. In doing so, you can slowly view failure as a positive – an opportunity to learn something new – rather than a sign that you have failed.

3. Create a Reason to Move On

Given all the time in the world, most of us probably would be perfectionists. We would spend hours on end perfecting that business report or that University essay. But we don’t have all the time in the world, with the deadline fast approaching, we do the best we can in the time available, hand in the finished product and forget about it. As we can’t change it past the due date, dwelling on it would be pointless.

Not every aspect of life is like this. But to prevent yourself from re-working something until it’s “perfect” you might benefit from creating a self-imposed deadline. Set a timer or pencil in a deadline date in your calendar. Whatever you do, just move on once your allocated time has passed.

Frequently Asked Questions

Perfectionism becomes self-sabotage when it leads to unhelpful behaviors: setting impossible standards, delaying work due to fear of doing it imperfectly, overthinking, or never feeling good enough. These behaviors actually block progress rather than help.

  • It causes productive procrastination: spending too much time on tiny details or assessing what’s “not perfect” instead of finishing. 

  • It encourages avoidance of challenges: people might avoid taking risk because “if it can’t be perfect, why try.”

Cognitive inflexibility refers to rigid thinking patterns — for example, all-or-nothing thinking where things are either perfect or a failure. When you believe only “perfect” counts, you may avoid tasks that you fear you can’t do perfectly.

Perfectionism can lead to elevated stress, anxiety, chronic worry, and dissatisfaction. Research cited in the article also links it to depression, and possibly suicidal thoughts when individuals continuously measure themselves against unachievable standards.

Some signals are:

  • You often rework or overanalyze finished work. 

  • You delay starting tasks because you doubt you’ll meet your high standard. 

  • You feel dissatisfied even when results are objectively good.

The article recommends several tactics:

  • Stop ruminating: once a task is done, avoid obsessing over minor imperfections; distract yourself or shift focus.

  • Track progress: perform weekly reviews of what you’ve accomplished to see how you’ve improved vs only focusing on what’s missing.

  • Set reasons to move on / deadlines: limit how long you allow yourself to perfect something; once a self-imposed or real deadline passes, move forward.

Yes, striving for quality and wanting to do one’s best is not by itself bad. It becomes harmful when standards are unrealistic, or when the drive for perfection prevents getting work done or leads to negative mental health outcomes. The article implies the need to distinguish healthy striving vs perfectionistic self-sabotage.

The Nirvana Fallacy is the logical error of assuming that one should reject realistic alternatives or good outcomes simply because they are not perfect. In the context of perfectionism, it’s when people reject or undervalue their achievements because they aren’t flawless.

FocusMe can help by blocking or limiting access to tasks that encourage over-refinement or reworking, helping prevent repeated revisits to already “done” tasks. By helping you to “move on” once something is finished (or deadline is reached), it reduces the opportunity to ruminate or over-polish.

Some helpful shifts include:

  • Viewing “imperfection as acceptable — recognizing that imperfection doesn’t equal failure. 

  • Seeing failure or mistakes as learning opportunities rather than proof of inadequacy. 

  • Focusing on growth and progress rather than achieving an ideal standard